Swap-bot Time: November 12, 2024 5:43 pm
www.swap-bot.com

Threes ratings for Jillow

Use the controls to the right to show only the ratings you are interested in.

Spencerette rated for Doctor Who in a Bag on Nov 30, 2012
3
rating
Comment: 12/19/12- Final swap item received along with an additional item as promised. Thank you for fulfilling your swap commitment! 11/30/12- Swap description called for a minimum of 7 item and only 6 were included in the swap. Per our pm convo on 10/14 a 7th item was promised, but to date nothing has arrived and I have received no further communication. I will be happy to update this if final item is received.
Response: so sorry forgot about it, i will send you two more things (instead of the promissed one) on monday
3
rating
Comment: Seriously? You´re the coordinator of the swap, and what do you send. Usually ATCs are made with sturdy paper or cardboard. This was not asked, so nothing I can do there. Calling this junk would be a lob. It is not even. One end is at least 0,5 mm wider than the other. It is also too high. Just writing a quote in bad handwriting with blue pall-point pen on piece of white paper? There is not way this is what you "would like to have in your collection". I want to have this in my collection to show what is a bad ATC is I ever teach to someone how to make ATCs. Usually, when I receive bad ATCs I can at least give out tips how to make the next better. This is just so bad, that I would recommend to start all over from the beginning. Well, this can always be seen as opinion, Even though if I would ever re-swap this, I would get a three for not sending an real ATC. You wrote the text of what to send. It included a note to the receiver. Even if I do not have the right to say what you would like to have in you collection or what is ATC, you did not meet the swap requirements. Ps. You marked it sent 22th oct, in the due day, but the stamp shows date 6th of oct. I am very disappointed. Since you have hearts and such in your rates, I wonder what gone in to you so that you sent this piece. I hope this is just bad joke, and I will tomorrow receive the real ATC. I shall re-rate in that case.
Response: In my opinion this is not a reason to rate a 3, personal taste can not be discussed

Rating Overview

Overall Hearts Stars Hosted
4.9184 50 20 26
Completed Fives Threes Ones
90 95 2 1
Type 1 Type 2 Type 3 Uncategorized
12 19 59 0

Show only: